The Silver Spoon cookbook
The Silver Spoon
Saturday, February 22 – 7:00pmFor February’s cookbook, we used The Silver Spoon. We’d previously done the Joy of Cooking, and now we’ve done Italy’s version with this bible of Italian home cooking that includes over 2,000 recipes. Originally published in Italy in 1950 by Italian design and architectural magazine Domus, a select group of cooking experts were commissioned to collect hundreds of traditional Italian recipes and make them available to a wider modern audience.

Catie hosted in her awesome home, where we were able to fit a pretty big group of 15 for a fun dinner and a chance to check out her collection of authentic movie props.

The Silver Spoon party

The Menu

Ricotta Dumplings in Broth - Brian

Ricotta Dumplings in Broth – Brian

Brian made Ricotta Dumplings in Broth. This was a yummy dish. The broth was a joy to just sit and sip, and to steal Revi’s very apt description – the dumplings tasted like little donuts.

Liver Pate - Cori

Liver Pate – Cori

Cori made Liver Pate. People’s feelings about liver were a mixed bag, but I like it and quite enjoyed the pate. It was a great spread for the nice bread slices she brought.

Small Cheese Crackers - Rachel

Small Cheese Crackers – Rachel

Rachel made Small Cheese Crackers. I think this is something of a misnomer, as they were less like crackers and more like cheese filled pastries, where the dough was a potato, flour, and butter mixture. Rachel felt that they could have used more cheese filling, and I agree.

Shrimp Bites - Catie

Shrimp Bites – Catie

Catie made Shrimp Bites. I was super excited about how these sounded, and I loved the green color from the parsley. But I was disappointed to find them a bit bland, and would cut way down on the amount of flour used.

Roasted Bell Peppers - Catie

Roasted Bell Peppers – Catie

Catie also made Roasted Bell Peppers. Such a simple dish, but one you can’t really go wrong with. The roasting brings out all of the natural sweetness of the peppers, and it only takes a little olive oil, garlic, and basil to punch it up.

Marinated Eggplant - Rachel

Marinated Eggplant – Rachel

Rachel also made Marinated Eggplant. This was a surprise favorite for me. It had so much depth of flavor with a little bit of spice and garlic, and especially the zing of the capers and the freshness of the mint.

Glazed Radishes - Alana

Glazed Radishes – Alana

I made Glazed Radishes. Radishes are so often served raw, so I was interested to experiment with cooking them. I really liked how it took away their bite and brought out a ton of unexpected sweetness and buttery goodness (there’s a lot of butter!). The recipe said to cover while cooking down the liquid, but after 45 minutes and little progress I removed the lid.

Salad with Herb Dressing - Paris

Salad with Herb Dressing – Paris

Paris made Salad with Herb Dressing. The salad had a bunch of varying crunchy textures that were really nice, and the flavor was great with the olives and wonderful dressing packed with a variety of different herbs.

Pasta Salad with Radicchio - Riley

Pasta Salad with Radicchio – Riley

Riley made Pasta Salad with Radicchio. When she introduced her dish, she said it was weird. I wasn’t sure what she meant by that, until I took a bite. It seemed like an odd mixture of things that didn’t know what it wanted to be – like both the salad contents and the dressing were compiled from whatever happened to be leftover in the fridge.

Pappardelle with Mushrooms - Shayna

Pappardelle with Mushrooms – Shayna

Shayna made Pappardelle with Mushrooms. I’m a fan of pasta and mushrooms, but this dish bordered on bland. It helped to grate on more of the extra parmesan that Shayna thankfully had brought along, but even then I think just a bit more salt would have enhanced the flavors.

Valle D’Aosta Polenta Pasticciata - Erin

Valle D’Aosta Polenta Pasticciata – Erin

Erin made Valle D’Aosta Polenta Pasticciata (baked polenta with fontina). While not a dish that would blow your mind with its uniqueness, it was polenta with a lot of melty cheese, so it was a crowd pleaser that no one was sad to be eating.

Spaghetti Carbonara - Laura

Spaghetti Carbonara – Laura

Laura made Spaghetti Carbonara. There’s a reason this is a popular Italian standard – what’s not to like about pasta with pancetta, garlic, egg, and cheese!? I love how the egg cooks from the heat of the pasta and helps all the flavors stick.

Sartu - Domenica

Sartu – Domenica

Domenica made Sartu. I had never heard of Sartu before, but it’s an incredible sort of risotto casserole with a filling surprise. Domenica started cooking it a day in advance because of all the filling elements (meatballs, mushrooms, chicken livers, sausage and cheese), and she had a hard time getting it out of the mold, but I was quite happy to eat the fruits of here labor.

Rabbit Stew with Walnuts - Erin

Rabbit Stew with Walnuts – Erin

Erin also made Rabbit Stew with Walnuts. I adore rabbit and am so excited on the rare occasions when I have the chance to eat it. This was in a tasty cream and wine sauce, but the meat wasn’t as tender as I’d hoped it would be, and I found the walnuts somehow distracting.

Strawberry Preserves - Anthony

Strawberry Preserves – Anthony

Anthony made Strawberry Preserves, which he served layered between strawberry cake and topped with whipped cream. I always enjoy his cakes and think this was a good application for the preserves, but can think of lots of other delicious ways to use them as well.

Chocolate Salami - Revi

Chocolate Salami – Revi

Revi made Chocolate Salami. As Revi put it – it’s basically fudge. And there’s nothing wrong with that! Plus I love the presentation of it, with the biscuits and the dusting of powdered sugar really making it look like salami.

The Verdict

The Silver Spoon is a tome. It was so massive that my shoulder hurt by the time I got it home from the local library. And it is dense – with multiple recipes on each page and very few pictures, it covers a lot of ground, which I think inevitably led to mixed results on the quality of the recipes. It was strangely specific in some aspects and vague in others – like the recipe I used calling for 1 lb 5 oz of radishes, but then saying to cover and simmer until syrupy without giving a timeframe. The formatting also left something to be desired – blocks of text without breaking recipes into steps, even for complicated dishes like the Sartu that took up a full page. Useful more as a reference book than a place to find inspiration or ease of use.

Want in? Join the Cookbook Club mailing list to be notified when new posts go live.

Comments are closed