Milk Street: The New Rules cookbook
Milk Street: The New Rules – Christopher Kimball

Saturday, June 19 – 6:00pm

After a long hiatus (thanks COVID) and a couple meh attempts at virtual gatherings (Cookbook Club just isn’t the same when you don’t get to eat all the yummy food), we are back! Our last cookbook before the pandemic shut us down was Milk Street: Tuesday Nights, so to try to pick back up where we left off 15 months ago, we did Milk Street: The New Rules for our reopening book.

After over a year of hiding out at home, people were very excited to finally be able to gather together again and share some good food. Luckily, Barbara opened her spacious backyard with its awesome outdoor kitchen setup to us, so we could accommodate a big group of hungry cookbook clubbers. It was such a joy to be able to see old faces, welcome new ones, and actually eat a meal together in person!

The Menu

Korean Spicy Chilled Noodles - Drew

Drew made Korean Spicy Chilled Noodles (Bibim Guksu). I usually prefer warm noodles to cold ones, but the moment he uncovered this dish and I got a whiff of it, I was dying for a taste. It turned out to taste as good as it smelled. One of my favorite dishes of the night.

Fettuccini with Olives and Arugula - Chris

Chris made Fettuccini with Olives and Arugula. This dish has all kinds of ingredients that I love, so I was a bit surprised to find it sort of plain. I think the flavors were all there, but I wanted more of the olives for the saltiness, more of the arugula for its bite, and more garlic and chilies for their kick.

Flatbread (Pizza) Dough - Barbara

Barbara made Flatbread (Pizza) Dough and provided a variety of toppings to allow people to make their own pizzas and cook them in her outdoor oven with pizza steel. I don’t think I’ve ever had dough that contains yogurt and honey before, but it was good and of course people had a great time making pizzas right there at the event.

Butternut Squash and Feta with Toasted Pearl Couscous - Austin

Austin made Butternut Squash and Feta with Toasted Pearl Couscous. Everyone I was eating with agreed that it would have been better with more feta. I also think a bit more dill would have helped to amp up the flavors in this dish.

Lentils with Swiss Chard and Pomegranate Molasses - Brian

Brian made Lentils with Swiss Chard and Pomegranate Molasses. The tangy sweetness of this dish was really nice, and I liked the crunch of the pickled chard stems.

Hot-and-Sour Curried Chickpeas - Alana

I made Hot-and-Sour Curried Chickpeas. I liked this recipe, and there was general agreement at the party that it was one of the favorite dishes. Lots of flavor from the garam masala and curry, offset nicely with the quick pickled onion and jalapeƱo. Sometimes jalapeƱos can be pretty mild, but this one had a good kick.

Tomato-Herb Salad with Sumac - Shayna

Shayna made Tomato-Herb Salad with Sumac. I think this is actually from the Milk Street website, not The New Rules book. It was super heavy on the dill, which sort of overwhelmed all the other flavors. To be honest, I don’t remember much about it except the dill.

Spicy Beef Salad with Mint and Cilantro - Hector

Hector made Spicy Beef Salad with Mint and Cilantro (Larb Neua). He used more lime juice and fish sauce than the recipe called for, but still felt that the flavors weren’t as forward as other versions of larb that he’s made before and preferred.

Cilantro, Scallion, Cilantro, Scallion, and Cucumber Salad - Hector and Cucumber Salad (Lao Hu Cai) - Hector

Hector also made Cilantro, Scallion, and Cucumber Salad (Lao Hu Cai). It went really well with the Larb. I liked both these dishes, but tend to agree with Hector that while the right flavor profiles were there, they weren’t as bold as these dishes traditionally are in their flavors.

Vietnamese Chicken Salad with Sweet Lime-Garlic Dressing - Amy

Amy made Vietnamese Chicken Salad with Sweet Lime-Garlic Dressing (Goi Ga). I loved the presentation and was really excited to eat this beautiful salad. But this was another dish where I felt like the flavors were there, but too scaled back for my liking.

Shiitake-Sesame Braised Chicken - Denise

Denise made Shiitake-Sesame Braised Chicken. I believe this one was also from the website, not the book. Regardless, I’m glad she made it because it was really tasty. It reminded me a lot of the Chinese clay pot chicken I ate as a kid, and I’ve always especially loved the mushrooms.

Southern Thai-Style Fried Chicken with Tangy-Sweet Chili Sauce - Martha

Martha made Southern Thai-Style Fried Chicken with Tangy-Sweet Chili Sauce. The crust on the chicken was crisp and full of flavor, though the chicken itself got a bit dry. I was glad for the chili sauce, which was indeed tangy and sweet.

Peruvian Chicken, Rice, and Cilantro Soup - Jeff

Jeff made Peruvian Chicken, Rice, and Cilantro Soup (Aguadito de Pollo). Although the flavors were subtle, I found myself eating spoonful after spoonful of this soup. I’m always happy when I get a chance to eat Peruvian food.

Apricots, Saffron and Tarragon Chicken en Cocotte - John

John made Apricots, Saffron and Tarragon Chicken en Cocotte. Look at those beautiful golden colors! The sweetness of the apricots and floral notes of the saffron were really nice together. I wish saffron wasn’t so expensive, because it’s so good!

Fennel-Brown Sugar Pork Ribs - Anthony

Anthony made Fennel-Brown Sugar Pork Ribs (Rosticciana). They were super tender inside with a perfectly browned crust from the spice rub, and I loved the fennel flavor against the sweetness of the brown sugar. Really yummy – one of my faves.

Since Milk Street: The New Rules didn’t have any dessert recipes, we had some bonus desserts not from the cookbook. Because cookbook clubbers love dessert! šŸ™‚

Peach, Pear, and Mulberry Tart - Revi

Revi made a peach, pear, and mulberry tart. As you can see, it was absolutely gorgeous. The peaches and mulberries were homegrown – so delicious!

Apricot Strawberry Black Pepper Pie - Erin

Erin made an apricot strawberry black pepper pie with an heirloom white corn and butter crust. In case you couldn’t tell, Erin is a pie professional! Black pepper isn’t something I’d typically think to put in dessert, but I really liked the subtle kick that it added.

Milk Bar Cornflake Chocolate Chip Marshmallow Cookies - Barbara

Barbara made Milk Bar Cornflake Chocolate Chip Marshmallow Cookies. People were gobbling them up as fast as she could get them out of the oven.

The Verdict

Milk Street: The New Rules has recipes driven by simple techniques for cooking. I liked that it covers a wide range of different kinds of food, though I found that with many of the dishes the flavors weren’t as bold as they would traditionally be in those cuisines. We speculated that maybe Christopher Kimball is trying to make the dishes accessible for people who are just being introduced to some types of food. So don’t be afraid to be a rule-breaker – amp up the seasonings a bit if you like, and definitely feel free to follow up with some dessert!

Want in? Join the Cookbook Club mailing list to be notified when new posts go live.